Approach · 6 min read

AI or scripted: which bot?

Some bots follow a script; others use AI to answer from your content. Many of the best do both. This guide explains the difference and how to choose.

Updated 15 November 2026 · Sources at the end

In short

  • Scripted bots follow buttons and set answers: predictable, cheap to run, limited.
  • AI bots answer in their own words from your content: flexible, but need guardrails and testing.
  • A mix suits most businesses: AI for questions, a script for money, bookings and data.
  • Whatever you choose, your business is responsible for what the bot says.

The difference

A scripted bot recognises a question (or offers buttons) and gives an answer you wrote. It never says anything you did not write. An AI bot uses a large language model to understand the question and write an answer, ideally only from content you provide, such as your help articles. A hybrid uses AI to understand and answer general questions, and switches to a script for anything that must be exact.

How the three approaches compare
What mattersScriptedAI from your contentHybrid
Understands varied wordingPartlyWellWell
Says only what you wroteYesNo: it rewordsYes, for scripted parts
Set-up effortWriting every pathPreparing content and guardrailsBoth, in smaller amounts
Running costPlatform fee onlyPlus AI usagePlus some AI usage
Best forQualifying leads, bookings, set formsLarge help centres, staff handbooksMost small business bots

When a script is better

Choose a script when every customer should get the same questions or the same exact answer: qualifying a lead, taking a booking, explaining a refund policy, or collecting details for a form. Scripts are easy to test because the paths are finite, and they cannot make things up.

When AI is better

Choose AI when there are too many questions to script, the content already exists (a help centre, a handbook), and a small risk of imperfect wording is acceptable. AI handles typos, long messages and questions asked in unexpected ways far better than keyword matching.

Accuracy is the main concern, for good reason. 56% of UK businesses using AI are concerned about bias and accuracy (opens in a new tab). Limit the bot to your own content, tell it to say when it does not know, keep exact facts in scripted answers, and keep a person in the loop to catch mistakes, as the CMA advises (opens in a new tab).

What AI costs to run

AI is charged by the amount of text processed, in tokens. List prices vary widely: Claude Haiku 5.5 costs $0.10 per million input tokens and $0.50 per million output tokens (opens in a new tab), and Gemini 3.1 Flash-Lite $0.25 and $1.50 (opens in a new tab); larger models cost many times more. By our own estimate, a six-turn support conversation with your content included uses around 20,000 input and 1,500 output tokens, which is well under a penny on the smallest models.

Helpdesk platforms often charge per resolved conversation instead, which can cost far more per chat. The running cost calculator compares both for your volumes.

You are responsible either way

Whether the bot follows a script or writes its own answers, the business answers for it. In Moffatt v Air Canada, a tribunal rejected the airline’s argument that it was not responsible for what its chatbot said (opens in a new tab). Test every approach with real questions before launch, and after every change.

The bot designer asks how your bot should answer in its channels step, and its test chat lets you see how a plan holds up before you choose a platform.

Questions people ask

Is AI always more expensive?

Not much on the smallest models, where AI usage can be fractions of a penny per conversation. The bigger costs are usually the platform fee and the time to prepare good content.

Can an AI bot be stopped from making things up?

The risk can be reduced a lot, by limiting it to your content, telling it to admit when it does not know, and testing. It cannot be removed entirely, which is why exact facts belong in scripted answers.

Can we start scripted and add AI later?

Yes, and it is often a sensible path. The questions customers ask the scripted bot become the content and tests for the AI version.

Design your bot in an afternoon

Free, no sign-up. Pick its jobs, write its answers, set the handoff, then test it in your browser and export the plan.